Global
BCA’s Global Growth Indicator, based on the price of copper, Korean equities, Kiwi bonds and the US ISM manufacturing survey, is gaining momentum. This is the clearest sign yet that before nCoV-2019 suddenly hit the Chinese economy, global industrial…
Highlights Global Growth Fears: Efforts to contain the China coronavirus outbreak risk creating the outcome that investors feared most in 2019 from the US-China trade war – weaker global growth and a severe disruption to supply chains worldwide. Monetary Policy Responses: Global bond yields have plunged as investors have piled into safe haven assets and priced in additional monetary easing from major central banks. Some of that decline in yields, however, may be a repricing of future rate hike probabilities with central banks like the Fed and ECB rethinking their inflation mandates and how to achieve them. Duration Strategy: Maintain a moderate below-benchmark cyclical (6-12 months) stance on overall interest rate duration in global fixed income portfolios. Yields now discount a significant hit to global economic growth from China. This outcome is far from certain, especially if China delivers more aggressive fiscal and monetary policy easing to mitigate the deflationary effects of the public health crisis. Feature Chart of the WeekBond Yields Have "Gone Viral" Global bond yields have declined sharply over the past two weeks, as investors have tried to process the potential implications of the China coronavirus outbreak. Scenes of empty streets in Chinese cities under quarantine look like something out of a Hollywood science fiction movie. Fears of a “zombie apocalypse” scenario plunging the global economy into recession are proliferating among doomsayers. The viral outbreak is interrupting global growth just as it is starting to show signs of recovery from the manufacturing slump of 2019 (Chart of the Week). Global bond yields had been slowly rising alongside that economic improvement, and risk premia in equity and credit markets had begun to narrow in earnest. Against that backdrop with markets priced for perfection, a massive public health crisis in the most marginal driver of global growth, China, was a potent trigger for a correction in risk assets. The story is obviously very fluid, with the number of infected continuing to grow in China and more cases being discovered across the world. At least 50 million Chinese citizens are now under quarantine, across several major cities. More countries are instituting travel bans to and from China, and important global companies like Apple are shuttering their China operations until further notice. The ultimate hit to global growth is yet to be determined, but measures being taken to slow the spread of the coronavirus will clearly have an impact on global trade, supply chain management and, thus, economic growth. This risks a repeat of the May-August period last year, when markets were pricing in the potential negative effects of US-China trade tariffs on global growth, triggering a major decline in global bond yields. A big driver of that bond rally last year was a shift towards expectations of easier global monetary policy. Those were largely realized as central banks cut rates while global growth was actually slowing. Bond yields now discount another round of rate cuts, most importantly from the US Federal Reserve, despite no formal indication (yet) that policymakers are looking to deliver more easing. The risk now is that investors will become too pessimistic, setting up a swing of the pendulum in the opposite direction if the hit to global growth from the virus is less than feared. On that note, a significant Chinese economic growth slowdown now appears fully priced into global bond yields. The risk now is that investors will become too pessimistic, setting up a swing of the pendulum in the opposite direction if the hit to global growth from the virus is less than feared. On that note, a significant Chinese economic growth slowdown now appears fully priced into global bond yields, as we discuss later in this Weekly Report. Breaking Down The Latest Decline In Global Bond Yields The decline in government bond yields in the developed markets (DM) has been sharpest since Chinese authorities confirmed human-to-human transmission of the coronavirus on Monday, January 20. That appears to be the date when investors began to take the outbreak much more seriously. Growth-sensitive assets like emerging market (EM) equities, copper and oil prices peaked on Friday, January 17, while measures of volatility like the US VIX index and US high-yield credit spreads troughed (Chart 2). The price of safe haven assets like gold and the Japanese yen have also increased since that “pre-virus peak” on January 17, as have bond volatility measures like the US MOVE index or European swaption volatility (Chart 3). Importantly, the increases in rates volatility have been smaller to date compared to mid-2019, when the “convexity” trade triggered an insatiable demand for duration that drove longer-maturity global bond yields sharply lower. Chart 2A Pullback In Growth-Sensitive Assets Chart 3A Mild Bid For Safe Havens Compared To 2019 A breakdown of the decline in the benchmark 10-year government bond yields in the major DM countries (US, Germany, Japan, the UK, Canada and Australia) since that “pre-virus peak” is shown in Table 1. Table 1Global Bond Yield Changes Since January 17, 2020 The biggest declines were in the US (-33bps), Canada (-29bps) and Australia (-23bps) where central bank monetary policy expectations also saw the largest shift. Our 12-month discounters, which measure the change in short-term interest rates over a one-year horizon priced into Overnight Index Swap (OIS) curves, have fallen by -30bps in the US, -26bps in Canada and -22bps in Australia – indicating that markets had fully priced in a rate cutting response to the coronavirus outbreak from the Fed, Bank of Canada and Reserve Bank of Australia. Bond yields have fallen to a lesser extent in Germany (-19bps), the UK (-11bps) and Japan (-7bps), but with very modest declines in our 12-month discounters for those three countries were policy interest rates are close to, or below, 0%. Therefore, the decline global yields over the past two weeks can, on the surface, be attributed to expectations of easier monetary policy in response to the potential hit to growth, and tightening of financial conditions as risk assets sell off, from the coronavirus (Chart 4). Chart 4Falling Yields Reflect Expectations Of More Rate Cuts In 2020... Chart 5...But Also Expectations Of Lower Rates For Longer Yet when looking at our estimates of the term premium for all six countries, the decline in the nominal 10-year yields is almost equal to the reduction in the term premium. On the surface, this would be consistent with the idea that the fall in yields is due to risk aversion driving up the demand for the safety of government bonds – and can hence be unwound if the news were to turn less gloomy on the spread of the coronavirus. Yet interest rates further out the yield curve have also fallen by similar amounts in all countries shown, when looking at 1-year interest rates, 5-years forward (the bottom row of Table 1). That decline in longer-dated forwards does correlate strongly with lower inflation expectations as measured by 10-year CPI swap rates (Chart 5). This suggests an alternative explanation for the recent fall in global bond yields that is not related to worries over the coronavirus: bond markets increasingly believe that policy interest rates will be lower for a lot longer. An alternative explanation for the recent fall in global bond yields that is not related to worries over the coronavirus: bond markets increasingly believe that policy interest rates will be lower for a lot longer. With the Fed and ECB now openly discussing changing their monetary policy frameworks to manage achievement of their statutory inflation targets more proactively, the hurdle for contemplating any interest rate hikes in the future is now much higher. Thus, central banks are giving forward guidance to the markets that rates will be lower. That is a message that would also be consistent with the decline in the term premium, to the extent that the premium is compensation for the future volatility of short-term interest rates. When looking at all the components, the message from the most recent decline in global bond yields may be more complex than simple virus-driven risk aversion. Our Duration Indicator continues to improve alongside rebounding global economic sentiment, signaling cyclical upward pressure on yields (Chart 7) – assuming, of course, that the hit to Chinese growth from the coronavirus outbreak is no worse than currently discounted in financial asset prices. In the case of US Treasuries, the bond rally also has a cyclical component, with yields now down to levels more consistent with the softer pace of growth indicated by the ISM Manufacturing index and the recent softening trend in US data surprises (Chart 6). Yet with US monetary policy and financial conditions still highly accommodative, the odds still favor some improvement in the current trend-like pace for US GDP growth that will, eventually, begin to put moderate upward pressure on Treasury yields again. Chart 6Low UST Yields Are Not Just A coronavirus Story Chart 7Global Yields Were Due For A Corrective Pullback A similar message is given when we look at global bond yields, more generally. Our Duration Indicator continues to improve alongside rebounding global economic sentiment, signaling cyclical upward pressure on yields (Chart 7) – assuming, of course, that the hit to Chinese growth from the coronavirus outbreak is no worse than currently discounted in financial asset prices. Bottom Line: Efforts to contain the China coronavirus outbreak risk creating the outcome that investors feared most in 2019 from the US-China trade war – weaker Chinese growth and a severe disruption to global supply chains. Global bond yields have plunged as investors have piled into safe haven assets and priced in additional monetary easing from major central banks. Some of that decline in yields, however, may be a repricing of future rate hike probabilities with central banks like the Fed and ECB rethinking their inflation mandates and how to achieve them. How Much China Weakness Is Priced Into Global Bond Yields? The China coronavirus outbreak, and the response to contain it, represents a potentially severe hit to Chinese – and global – economic growth. A lot of comparisons have been made to the 2003 SARS outbreak to try and find a comparable past event. However, as our colleagues at BCA Research Emerging Markets Strategy have noted, China’s economy is so much larger now, rendering comparisons of the economic impact from SARS to that of the coronavirus far less meaningful.1 For example, China’s GDP at purchasing power parity accounts for 19.3% of world GDP compared to 8.3% in 2002 before the SARS outbreak occurred. China’s share of the global consumption of various industrial metals has surged, as well, from between 10-20% in 2002 to 50-60% today. A simple alternative way to measure the impact of any virus-driven slowing of Chinese economic growth would be to calculate the reduction in full-year 2020 GDP growth relative to consensus forecasts. In this sense, the comparison is made to current expectations rather than to a past episode – an approach that should be far more relevant for predicting the response of financial asset prices today. For example, the Bloomberg consensus expectation for Chinese nominal GDP growth for all of 2020 is currently 7.2%. Using that rate and the level of nominal GDP from 2019, we can calculate an expected level for nominal GDP for 2020. We can then make some simplifying assumptions for the impact on full-year growth from an extended period of lost output from the quarantines, government-ordered factory shutdowns and extended holidays, travel bans, etc. Assuming that one full month of expected nominal GDP growth is lost (i.e. 1/12th of the expected increase in the level of nominal China GDP), the full-year growth rate falls to 6.6% Assuming that two full months of expected nominal GDP growth are lost, the full year growth rate falls to 6.0% Global bond yields now reflect a considerable slowdown of Chinese economic activity from the coronavirus, representing between 1-2 months of expected full-year 2020 nominal GDP growth that will be lost. The last time that Chinese nominal GDP growth fell to a sub-7% pace was back in 2015 (Chart 8). The Caixin manufacturing PMI reached a low of 47.2 then, 3.9 points below the current level of 51.1. The level of global bond yields, using our “Major Countries” GDP-weighted aggregate, was at 0.72% - similar to today’s level. Global growth ex-China was also at similarly subdued levels in 2015 (i.e. the US ISM manufacturing index was below 50). Chart 8Global Yields Already Priced For A 2015-Type Slowdown In China Chart 9New Stimulus Measures In China Are Inevitable We conclude from this admittedly simple analysis that global bond yields now reflect a considerable slowdown of Chinese economic activity from the coronavirus, representing between 1-2 months of expected full-year 2020 nominal GDP growth that will be lost. The final impact on China economic growth in 2020 will likely be less than that full hit, as Chinese policymakers will surely look to ease monetary and fiscal policy to offset the hit to the economy (Chart 9). While BCA’s China strategists do not currently expect the same magnitude of policy responses as was seen in 2015/16, there will likely be enough to at least partially offset the hit to growth from containing the virus. In terms of timing, the critical point for financial markets – and bond yields – will be when the growth rate of new coronavirus cases peaks. During the 2003 SARS episode, global equity markets bottomed when that number of new cases peaked, which we believe to be a useful template for timing a potential turning point in the “fear narrative” (Chart 10). The number of new coronavirus infections continues to rise, however, suggesting that risk assets and bond yields will likely remain subdued in the near term. Chart 10Markets Bottomed In 2003 When The SARS Infection Rate Peaked When that turn does happen, any potential increase in global bond yields will be driven more by unwinding the declines in real yields and term premia of the past two weeks shown earlier in this report in Table 1. Chart 11Only A Pause In The Cyclical Upturn In Yields? That suggests a potential rise in the 10-year US Treasury yield of as much as 30bps, and a 23bps increase in the 10-year German bund yield. An additional increase of 5-10bps for both markets could come from higher inflation expectations, although that would likely need to be accompanied by a sizeable rebound in the price of oil and other industrial commodities. We are not seeing signs in our most favored leading indicators – like our global LEI diffusion index or the global ZEW index – suggesting that the next cyclical move in yields will be lower. We acknowledge that the recent fall in yields has gone against our expectations of a moderate grind higher global bond yields in 2020. However, we are not seeing signs in our most favored leading indicators – like our global LEI diffusion index or the global ZEW index – suggesting that the next cyclical move in yields will be lower (Chart 11). We will monitor those indicators in the coming months for any signs of a serious hit to global growth from the coronavirus outbreak. Bottom Line: Maintain a moderate below-benchmark cyclical (6-12 months) stance on overall interest rate duration in global fixed income portfolios. Yields now discount a significant hit to global economic growth from China. This outcome is far from certain, especially if China delivers more aggressive fiscal and monetary policy easing to mitigate the deflationary effects of the public health crisis. Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see BCA Research Emerging Markets Strategy Weekly Report, "Coronavirus Versus SARS: Mind The Economic Differences", dated January 30, 2020, available at ems.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
The Global Manufacturing PMI improved marginally in January, hitting a level of 50.4. Positively, our diffusion index is bottoming, which suggests that the global economic slowdown is over. The problem is that the outbreak of nCoV-2019 will likely cause this…
GAA DM Equity Country Allocation Model Update The GAA DM Equity Country Allocation model is updated as of January 31, 2020. The model made a significant change in its allocation this month. The allocation to the US is now overweight from neutral previously. Japan, the UK and France remain the three largest underweight countries, as shown in Table 1. Table 1Model Allocation Vs. Benchmark Weights As shown in Table 2 and Charts 1, 2 and 3, the overall model outperformed the MSCI World benchmark in January by 9 bps, driven by the outperformance from the Level 2 mode (21 bps). The Level 1 model also generated two basis points of outperformance. Since going live, the overall model has outperformed by 80 bps, with 297 bps of outperformance by Level 2 model, offset by 55 bps of underperformance from Level 1. Table 2Performance (Total Returns In USD %) Chart 1GAA DM Model Vs. MSCI World Chart 2GAA US Vs. Non US Model (Level 1) Chart 3GAA Non US Model (Level 2) For more on historical performance, please refer to our website http://gaa.bcaresearch.com/trades/allocation_performance. For more details on the models, please see Special Report, “Global Equity Allocation: Introducing The Developed Markets Country Allocation Model,” dated January 29, 2016, available at https://gaa.bcaresearch.com. Please note that the overall country and sector recommendations published in our Monthly Portfolio Update and Quarterly Portfolio Outlook use the results of these quantitative models as one input, but do not stick slavishly to them. We believe that models are a useful check, but structural changes and unquantifiable factors need to be considered as well when making overall recommendations. GAA Equity Sector Selection Model The GAA Equity Sector Model (Chart 4) is updated as of January 31, 2019. Chart 4Overall Model Performance The model’s relative tilts between cyclicals and defensives have changed compared to last month. The global growth proxies used in our model continue providing positive signals. This in turn led the model to maintain its overweight on multiple cyclical sectors. The valuation component remains muted across all sectors except Energy. Global central bankers will continue to keep monetary policy accommodative, leading the model to favor a mixed bag of cyclical and defensive sectors. The model is now overweight four sectors in total, three cyclical sectors versus one defensive sector. These are Consumer Discretionary, Information Technology, Communication Services, and Health Care. For more details on the model, please see the Special Report “Introducing the GAA Equity Sector Selection Model”, dated July 27, 2016, as well as the Sector Selection Model section in the Special Alert “GAA Quant Model Updates”, dated March 1, 2019 available at https://gaa.bcaresearch.com. Table 3Overall Model Performance Table 4Current Model Allocations Xiaoli Tang Associate Vice President xiaoliT@bcaresearch.com Amr Hanafy Research Associate amrh@bcaresearch.com
Last Friday, BCA’s Global Investment Strategy service wrote that beyond their anticipation of stronger global growth for 2020, another factor is supporting stocks: corporate buybacks. The combination of copious buybacks and dearth of IPOs has caused the S&P…
Highlights The SARS episode of 2003 suggests that the panic over the coronavirus will only subside when the number of new cases peaks. Although the latest data is somewhat encouraging, it is far from clear that we have reached that point. Provided the outbreak is contained, global equities should move higher over the course of the year. US companies remain net buyers of shares, implying that households and other holders have been net sellers. But against a backdrop of rising incomes, high savings, and improving confidence, households have also wanted to own more equities. How can households be net sellers of stocks while simultaneously increasing their equity exposure? There is only one answer: Share prices need to rise. The process will only stop once households decide they own enough stocks. In the US, while household equity holdings are on the high side as a share of household wealth, this is counterbalanced by the fact that the earnings yield on stocks is well above the yields on competing assets. Outside the US, household ownership of equities is quite low while the equity risk premium is still high. Going Viral We upgraded global equities after markets plunged in late 2018 and have remained overweight stocks on a 12-month horizon to this day. However, we indicated three weeks ago that equities had become technically overbought and would likely need to consolidate their gains. Thus, while we kept our 12-month views unchanged, we downgraded our tactical 3-month view on global stocks from overweight to neutral, while also advising clients with short horizons to boost exposure to cash and government bonds at the expense of riskier credit (our entire set of views can be found in the Global Investment Strategy View Matrix at the back of this report). Since then, the outbreak of the coronavirus has added another headwind to the near-term outlook for stocks. Many commentators have drawn comparisons between today’s outbreak and the SARS epidemic in 2003. The SARS episode imposed a significant but short-lived economic toll on the affected countries. While Chinese GDP growth fell to 3.4% in Q2 of 2003, it surged back to 15.7% in Q3, leaving the overall level of GDP down about 1% for the year as a whole relative to what would have transpired if the virus had never emerged.1 The broader Asia-Pacific region experienced a hit to growth of around 0.5%. In contrast, growth in developed economies was barely affected. Even in Canada, where 44 people died from SARS, the outbreak shaved only around 0.1% from the level of GDP in 2003, according to the Bank of Canada.2 The outbreak of the coronavirus has added another headwind to the near-term outlook for stocks. The obvious problem with the SARS analogy is that it is based on a sample of one. We do not know how this new strain of the virus compares to SARS or, for that matter, the Spanish flu, which killed 50-to-100 million people (3%-to-5% of the world’s population at the time). We do not even know if the full scope of the SARS outbreak was as fleeting as what we remember, since in a cosmic multiverse there will be a tendency to recall life-or-death outcomes more favorably than they actually were (I will have more to say about the financial implications of this in a future special report). Chart 1The Coronavirus Is Spreading Faster Than SARS Did What we do know is that, to date, the coronavirus has spread more quickly than SARS (Chart 1). It is not clear if that is because of faster, more accurate reporting methods or because the virus is more communicable. The Chinese Minister of Health has said that this new virus, unlike SARS, can be transmitted while people are still asymptomatic. While others have cast doubt on this claim, if it turns out to be correct, the coronavirus may be much more difficult to control. Viruses often become less lethal as they mutate because a virus that kills its host is also a virus that kills itself. Unfortunately, in a world of mass travel, a virus can spread across the globe before it has time to lose potency. The typical seasonal flu kills less than 0.1% of those who contract it. Most estimates suggest that SARS killed 10%-15% of infected patients. The Spanish flu killed a similar percentage. The death rate from the coronavirus is currently tracking at 2%-to-3%. However, it is possible that this estimate will rise. The vast majority of the people who have contracted the coronavirus are still sick. In fact, more people have died from it than have fully recovered (Chart 2). Thus, an honest assessment would simply admit that we do not know how bad this potential pandemic will get. Chart 2How Will This End: Outbreak, Epidemic, Or Pandemic? Chart 3Markets Bottomed As The SARS Infection Rate Was Peaking What should investors do? The SARS experience suggests that risk assets will only bottom when the number of new cases peaks (Chart 3). It is not clear that we have reached this point yet. While the number of new cases reported by China’s National Health Commission has stabilized over the past two days, this could just be a temporary respite (Chart 4). Until the rate at which new cases are diagnosed begins a clear downward trend, a somewhat cautious stance towards risk assets is warranted. Global Growth Should Recover Provided the outbreak is contained during the coming weeks, global equities should move higher over the course of the year. This is partly because global growth should pick up thanks to the lagged effects of last year’s decline in bond yields, an improvement in the global manufacturing inventory cycle, and diminished Brexit and trade war risks. Continued fiscal/credit stimulus out of China should also help. China spends less on health care than almost all other countries (Chart 5). It is likely that the past few weeks will prompt the government to increase social spending. Chart 4The Number Of New Cases Has Stagnated Over The Past Two Days Chart 5China: Public Spending On Health Care Has Room To Catch Up Higher Equity Prices: Just A Matter Of Arithmetic? Chart 6There Is A Structural Decline In Listed Companies In The US Chart 7The Supply Of US Stocks Has Been Drying Up In addition to stronger global growth, there is another factor supporting stocks which receives insufficient attention and is worth highlighting in this week’s report: corporate buybacks. US companies have repurchased about 3% of their shares every year for the past decade. On the flipside, only 110 companies went public last year, less than a third of the number of new listings in 1996-99. In fact, the number of publicly traded domestic companies has fallen by over 40% since 1996 (Chart 6). The combination of copious buybacks and dearth of IPOs has caused the S&P divisor – a broad measure of the total number of split-adjusted shares outstanding – to decline by a cumulative 9% since 2011. Between 1990 and 2004, the divisor increased by 40% (Chart 7). If companies are net buyers of stocks, then households and other holders must be net sellers of stock. But this raises an obvious question: What if households also want to be net buyers of stocks? Chart 8Households Are Bullish Chart 9High Equity Ownership By Households Translates Into Poor Long-Term Returns This question is highly relevant in today’s environment, where unemployment is low, wage growth is accelerating, the household savings rate is high, consumer confidence is strong, and a higher-than-average percentage of people expect stocks to increase in the coming months (Chart 8). Arithmetically, there is only one way that households can be net sellers of stocks while simultaneously increasing their equity exposure: Share prices need to rise. At what point will share prices stop rising? That depends on two things: 1) How much stock market wealth households hold relative to other assets; and 2) The risk-adjusted rate of return that households expect from stocks compared to other assets. Stock returns are highest when equity holdings are low, but sentiment towards stocks is improving. Conversely, returns are lowest when equity holdings are high, but stock market sentiment is deteriorating (Chart 9 and Table 1). Table 1Equity Returns Tend To Suffer When Bulls Are Losing Conviction The latter typically occurs during economic downturns when earnings are falling and risk aversion is rising. Thus, it is no surprise that recessions and equity bear markets tend to overlap (Chart 10). Chart 10Recessions And Bear Markets Tend To Overlap Where Things Stand Today In the US, household equity holdings are on the high side. According to Fed data and our own estimates, households currently hold 33% of their financial assets in stocks (Chart 11). This is higher than in 2007, but still below the dotcom peak of 39%. Similarly, the monthly asset allocation survey conducted by the American Association of Individual Investors shows a somewhat elevated allocation to equities, although one that is still broadly on par with the 2003-2007 and post-2014 averages (Chart 12). Chart 11US Household Equity Holdings Are On The High Side (I) Chart 12US Household Equity Holdings Are On The High Side (II) Chart 13Relative Valuations Favor Stocks One major difference with prior occasions when US equity allocations were elevated is that the earnings yield on stocks at present is still quite a bit higher than the yield on competing assets such as cash and bonds (Chart 13). While this is mainly because interest rates are so low, it does suggest that households may seek to further increase their equity allocations provided that the economy continues to perform well. Foreign companies have been less aggressive re-purchasers of their own shares than their US peers. That said, household equity ownership is significantly lower outside the US (Chart 14). The spread between equity earnings yields and bond yields is also higher abroad, reflecting the fact that both PE multiples and interest rates are generally lower outside the US. Given that investors tend to favor companies listed in their home country, efforts by non-US investors to increase their equity allocations will primarily benefit stock markets outside the US. In addition, stronger global growth tends to favor EM and European equities, largely because stock markets in those regions have more of a cyclical bent (Chart 15). Thus, on balance, we recommend that investors overweight non-US stocks this year. Chart 14Equity Ownership By Households Is Lower Outside The US Chart 15Stronger Global Growth Tends To Favor A Cyclical Bias In Equity Allocation Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Jong-Wha Lee and Warwick J. McKibbin, “Globalization and Disease: The Case of SARS,” Brookings Institution, dated February 2004. 2 Please see Monetary Policy Report, Bank of Canada, October 2003. Global Investment Strategy View Matrix MacroQuant Model And Current Subjective Scores Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Next week, we will focus on the following key items: The spread of nCoV-2019: We will continue to monitor how the coronavirus is spreading, especially as a case of human-to-human transmission has been reported in the US. In all likelihood, this disease will…
It is tempting to compare the potential impact of the current coronavirus outbreak on the global economy and financial markets with that of SARS in the spring of 2003. The correction in global equities due to the SARS outbreak lasted only a couple of days…
The coronavirus scare is the catalyst for the recent correction. The true cause is that the stock market had reached a point of groupthink-triggered instability and therefore needed the slightest catalyst to correct. The bond yield 6-month impulse had…
Highlights Collective market signals suggest a low but non-negligible probability of a dollar spike due to the coronavirus. Stay long the yen as a portfolio hedge. Short CHF/JPY bets also make sense. Our limit sell on the gold/silver ratio was triggered at 90. Place a stop at 95, with an initial target of 80. Feature Chart I-1Watching Market Signals Investors can generally be classified in two camps. There are those who are predisposed to being risk averse. As such, capital preservation trumps the desire for outsized returns. For such investors, defensive equities such as staples and utility stocks, fixed-income assets, or even gold tend to be the favored vehicles over time. At the opposite end of the spectrum are the investors who desire hopping on and riding the next growth unicorn. Their favored investment universe can include technology and biotech concerns, but can also span industries such as automotive and food. The key, however, is that their inherent disposition is to multiply returns rather than preserve capital. There is a crucial difference between this bias and a risk-on/risk-off environment. For example, in a risk-on environment, the more prudent investor might choose high-yielding government bonds, while the high flyer will be in the S&P 500 or private equity. In the currency world, the “preservationist” might choose the euro as an anti-dollar play despite negative yields, while the “high flyer” would rather be in the New Zealand dollar or the Norwegian krone. The oscillation between these two bipolar universes can be measured in various ways, but one that has been prescient in gauging the direction for currency markets is the ratio between the S&P 500 index and gold prices. In general, whenever the S&P 500 has been outperforming gold, the dollar has tended to soar, and vice versa (Chart I-1). As a closed economy, US markets are generally more defensive. So even in a risk-off environment, this ratio can capture the preference for capital preservation versus growth. The collective signals from financial markets suggest there is a low probability of a dollar spike. The SPX/Gold ratio hit a peak of 2.5 in the last quarter of 2018 and has since been exhibiting a bearish pattern of lower highs, with the latest rise peaking a nudge below 2.2. Our belief is that it is less a story of greed versus fear, and more an indication of a powerful underlying preference for investors being revealed in asset prices. Gauging FX Market Signals The coronavirus outbreak has been dominating market headlines in recent weeks. We are not infectious disease specialists, so cannot provide any insight on the potential impact on growth and/or the probability for the virus to become much more widespread. However, the collective signals from financial markets suggest there is a low probability of a dollar spike. The rise in the dollar has been relatively on par with the SARS experience of 2002 (Chart I-2A and Chart I-2B). Back then, the Chinese economy had a much smaller effect on global growth, and so far, the number of reported cases is outpacing the SARS experience. So, it is possible that given the dollar bull market of the last decade or so, there is a dearth of new buyers in the greenback. Chart I-2ARun Of The Mill Virus ? (1) Chart I-2BRun Of The Mill Virus ? (2) The most recent fall in the S&P 500 index versus gold is definitely a sign of risk aversion, but the much broader peak almost two years ago might be signaling an outright shift in the investment universe. In other words, capital preservation might now be best sought outside US bourses. If this is the case, cheap and unloved value stocks will provide better shelter compared to the growth champions of the last decade. It is interesting that emerging market cyclical stocks (where the epicenter of the crisis is) have not underperformed defensives in a meaningful way during the latest riot (Chart I-3). The typical narrative is that the dollar is now a high-yielding currency within the G10. That means it has now become the object of carry trades. Should the investment universe be shifting to one of prudence, it is plausible though not probable that the greenback will provide both functions. Chart I-3Mixed Message From Cyclicals Versus Defensives Chart I-4Correlation Break Down Or Unsustainable Gap? The absolute collapse in the gold-to-bond ratio further confirms that after almost a decade of underperformance, hard money might be coming back into favor versus yield plays (Chart I-4). Gold was a monetary aggregate for centuries, and continues to stand as a viable threat to dollar liabilities. This is not only visible in the rampant accumulation of gold by foreign central banks, notably Russia and China, but also by the breakout in gold in almost every currency, including safe-havens like the Swiss franc and the Japanese yen (Chart I-5). The absolute collapse in the gold-to-bond ratio further confirms that after almost a decade of underperformance, hard money might be coming back into favor. Data from the US Treasury confirms that foreign entities have been fleeing US bond markets at among the fastest pace in recent years. On a rolling 12-month total basis, the US saw an exodus of about US$250 billion in Treasurys from foreigners, one of the largest on record (Chart I-6). Foreign private investors are still net buyers of US Treasurys, but the downtrend in purchases in recent years is evident. In addition, this helps explain why gold has also outperformed Treasurys over this period. Chart I-5Soft Versus Hard ##br##Money Chart I-6Official Data Shows Less Preference For Treasurys The US dollar’s reserve status remains intact for now. But subtle shifts in this exorbitant privilege are worth monitoring. If balance-of-payment dynamics continue to head in the wrong direction, as they are now, this will favor hard money and non-US assets, while accelerating divestment out of US Treasurys. This is irrespective of whether we enter a risk-on versus risk-off environment. A good proxy for whether the US government was prudent or profligate over the past four decades can be measured by the gap between unemployment relative to NAIRU (the so-called unemployment gap) and the corresponding budget deficit. In simple terms, full employment should be accompanied by balanced budgets, while governments can step in during recessions to put a floor under aggregate demand. Not surprisingly, using this simple rule, sound fiscal policies in the US were usually accompanied by a strong dollar, and vice versa. Chart I-7The Risk To Long Dollar Positions Over the next five years, the US Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that the US budget deficit will swell to 4.6% of GDP. Assuming the current account deficit remains stable, this will pin the twin deficits at 7.2% of GDP. This assumes no recession, which would have the potential to boost the deficit even further. In the last forty years, there has not been any prolonged period where twin deficits in the US have been expanding while the dollar has been in a bull market (Chart I-7). In a nutshell, even though the coronavirus is dominating headlines, the lack of a more pronounced greenback strength can be pinpointed to a rising number of negative market signals. Our bias is that when this eventually rolls over and global growth picks up in earnest, dollar bulls may be forced to capitulate. Bottom Line: We are not downplaying the potential impact of the coronavirus, but are skeptical of its ability to catapult the dollar higher. We are short the DXY index, with a target of 90 and a stop at 100. Stick with it. Bullish Both Gold And Silver, But Go Short The GSR If we are right, then both gold and silver will tend to rise in an environment where the dollar is falling. That said, the gold/silver ratio (GSR) hit a three-decade high of 93.3 last summer, opening up an arbitrage opportunity. The history of these reversals is that they tend to be powerful, quick, and extremely volatile (Chart I-8). This not only paves the way for an excellent entry point to short gold versus silver, but provides important information on the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pick-up in economic (or manufacturing) activity. The ratio of the velocity of money between the US and China has tended to track both the gold/silver ratio and the dollar closely. Just like gold, silver benefits from low interest rates, plentiful liquidity, and the incentive for fiat money debasement. However, the gold/silver ratio is sitting near two standard deviations above its mean. Meanwhile, over the past century, the peak in GSR has been around 100. The gold/silver ratio tends to rally ahead of an economic slowdown, but then peaks when growth is still weak but liquidity conditions are plentiful enough to affect the outlook for future growth. This appears to be the case today. The simple reason is that silver has more industrial uses than gold (Chart I-9). Chart I-8GSR At A Speculative Extreme Chart I-9No Recession = Buy Silver The ratio of the velocity of money between the US and China has tended to track both the gold/silver ratio and the dollar closely (Chart I-10). A falling ratio signifies that the number of times money is changing hands in China is outpacing that number in the US. This also tends to coincide with a preference for US versus non-US assets, since animal spirits (as measured by money velocity) tend to be pronounced in places where returns on capital are higher. Silver is a more volatile metal than gold. Part of the reason is that the silver market is thinner, with future open interest that is about one-third that of gold. As such, silver tends to rise faster than gold during precious metal bull markets (Chart I-11). Chart I-10Falling GSR = Rising Manufacturing Activity Chart I-11Silver Is More Volatile Than Gold This brings us to the sweet spot for silver. Even if global growth remains tepid over the next few months, due to a rise in infections from the coronavirus, a lot of the bad news is already reflected in a high GSR. This means the potential for upside will have to be nothing short of a deep recession. Relative speculative positioning favors gold, which is positive from a contrarian standpoint. Ditto for relative sentiment. More often than not, a positive signal from both these indicators has been a good timing tool for a selloff in the GSR. If global growth bottoms, then the rise in silver prices could be explosive. Silver fabrication demand benefits from new industries such as solar and a flourishing “cloud” industry that are capturing the new manufacturing landscape. Meanwhile, we are also entering a window where any pickup in demand could lead to a sizeable increase in the physical silver deficit. Bottom Line: A falling GSR provides important information about the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pickup in economic activity. We remain bullish on both gold and silver, but a trading opportunity has opened up for a short GSR position. Housekeeping Chart I-12AUD Will Follow Asian Currencies Our limit buy on the Australian dollar was triggered at 68 cents. We discussed the Aussie at length in our report dated January 17.1 Place an initial target at 0.75 cents and a tight stop at 0.66. The near-term risk to this trade is any escalation in virus infections that will collectively send Asian currencies into a tailspin (Chart I-12). Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "On AUD And CNY," dated January 17, 2020, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been positive: The Markit manufacturing PMI fell to 51.7 while the services component increased to 53.2 in January. The Dallas Fed manufacturing index improved from -3.2 to -0.2 in January. Moreover, the Richmond Fed manufacturing index soared to 20 in January. Durable goods orders increased by 2.4% month-on-month in December. The trade deficit widened further to $68.3 billion from $63 billion in December. Annualized GDP growth was unchanged at 2.1% year-on-year in Q4. Initial jobless claims fell to 216K from 223K for the week ended January 24th. The DXY index appreciated by 0.1% this week. While the coronavirus spurred worries about a further slowdown in the global economy, the impact on the US remains to be seen. On Wednesday, the Fed committee voted unanimously to keep interest rates on hold at 1.75% and concluded that the current rate is appropriate to support sustained expansion of the US economy. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been mostly positive: The Markit manufacturing PMI jumped to 47.8 in January while the services PMI fell slightly to 52.2. The German IFO current assessment index increased to 99.1 from 98.8 in January, while expectations component fell to 92.9. The economic sentiment indicator increased to 102.8 from 101.3 in January. The unemployment rate fell further to 7.4% in December from 7.5% the prior month. The euro has been flat against the US dollar this week. Though the German IFO expectations component disappointed, the overall assessment has shown tentative signs of recovery. More importantly, changes in the manufacturing PMI indices, especially in Germany, are staging the V-shaped recovery we have been expecting. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 On Money Velocity, EUR/USD And Silver - October 11, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been positive: Consumer confidence was unchanged at 39.1 in January. Services PPI increased by 2.1% year-on-year in December. Headline inflation increased to 0.8% year-on-year from 0.5% in December. Both manufacturing and services PMIs increased to 49.3 and 52.1, respectively in January. The Japanese yen appreciated by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. The flare up in risk aversion was a very potent catalyst, given the yen had become unloved and under owned. Persistent global risks, including Mid East tensions, and more recently, the spread of coronavirus, all warrant holding the Japanese yen as a portfolio hedge. Our last weekly report discussed why we prefer the Japanese yen to the Swiss franc as portfolio insurance. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Signposts For A Reversal In The Dollar Bull Market - November 1, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the UK have been solid: Both Markit manufacturing and services PMIs soared to 49.8 and 52.9 respectively in January. Nationwide housing prices increased by 1.9% year-on-year in January, compared with 1.4% the previous month. The saucer-shaped bottom in home prices is becoming more and more evident. The British pound has been flat against the US dollar this week. On Thursday, the BoE decided to leave interest rates unchanged at 0.75%. The fact that there were only two dissenters, in line with the previous month, suggests that rising bets for a rate cut were misplaced. The UK is due to leave the EU as of January 31st and enter a transition period that is supposed to last until December 31st 2020. The immediate aftermath of the exit will be business as usual. Trading strategy on the pound should be a buy on dips. We will continue to explore opportunities in GBP in upcoming reports. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdom: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mixed: The NAB business conditions index fell to 3 from 4 in December. Moreover, the business confidence index decreased to -2 from 0. Headline inflation increased to 1.8% year-on-year from 1.7% in the fourth quarter. Import prices increased by 0.7% quarter-on-quarter, while export prices plunged by 5.2% quarter-on-quarter in Q4. The Australian dollar fell by 2.1% against the US dollar this week, triggering our limit buy position at AUD/USD 0.68. Despite temporary challenges from the bushfires and the coronavirus, we continue to hold our base case view that global growth is likely to rebound in the next 12-to-18 months, which is bullish for the Aussie dollar. Report Links: On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been positive: Headline inflation increased to 1.9% year-on-year in Q4, compared with 1.5% the previous quarter. It also beat expectations of 1.8%. The trade balance shifted to a surplus of NZ$547 million in December. Goods exports rose by 4.8% year-on-year to NZ$5.5 billion, while imports fell by 5.4% year-on-year to NZ$5 billion. Shortly after the rise along with inflation data, the New Zealand dollar fell by more than 2% this week, amid growing risk aversion. New Zealand, as a chief exporter of agricultural products, bore a good brunt of speculative selling. Assuming infections peak in the coming weeks, we remain positive on the kiwi as the Chinese government is likely to inject more stimulus into the economy. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been mostly positive: Retail sales increased by 0.9% month-on-month in November. The Bloomberg Nanos confidence index rose to 56.5 from 56.1 for the week ended January 24th. The Canadian dollar fell by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. As a petrocurrency, the risk of much reduced travel hit the loonie. We have written at length in various reports about the loonie, but the bottom line is that Canada benefits less than other petrocurrencies in oil bull markets. Ergo, the underperformance of short CAD/NOK and long AUD/CAD positions this week is expected. In other news, Trump has signed the new USMCA bill into law this week, leaving Canada the only member of the trilateral deal that has yet to ratify the agreement. Report Links: The Loonie: Upside Versus The Dollar, But Downside At The Crosses Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been mixed: The trade surplus narrowed for a fourth consecutive month in December, falling to CHF 2 billion. Real exports decreased by 3.4% month-on-month while real imports grew by 0.2% month-on-month. The ZEW expectations index fell to 8.3 from 12.5 in January. The KOF leading indicator jumped to 100.1 from 96.2 in January. The Swiss franc has been more or less flat against the US dollar this week. The fall in exports of chemical and pharmaceutical production was the main driver behind the decrease in the Swiss trade balance in December. The SNB is walking a fine line. The improvement in the KOF leading indicator, along with rising inflation and PMI data is definitely a source of comfort, but the surge in EUR/CHF will hurt competitiveness and warrant stealth intervention. Buy EUR/CHF at 1.06. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Notes On The SNB - October 4, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been negative: Retail sales fell by 2% month-on-month in December. The Norwegian krone fell by 1.9% against the US dollar this week. The WTI crude oil price plunged by 20% since the peak earlier this month, due to a combination of falling global travel demand, eased Iran tensions and a bearish EIA inventory report. That being said, our Commodity & Energy strategists continue to be bullish energy prices and expect the WTI crude oil price to reach $63/bbl in 2020, based on recovering global demand and supply constraints. This should eventually lift the Norwegian krone. OPEC is scheduled to meet early March, and plunging prices could be a catalyst for the cartel to cut production. Report Links: On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Producer prices increased by 1.3% year-on-year in December. The trade surplus shrank to SEK 0.3 billion from SEK 2.7 billion in December. Retail sales grew by 3.4% year-on-year in December. Consumer confidence marginally fell to 92.6 from 94.7 in January, while business confidence jumped to 97.4 in January, the highest in seven months. The Swedish krona fell by 1.3% against the US dollar this week. Recent Swedish data has been disappointing given the steep decline during the trade war, but we are beginning to see second-derivative improvements. The trade surplus is rising on a year-on-year basis. Particularly noteworthy was the improvement in business confidence, which has historically led the Swedbank PMI index tick for tick. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

